Paleo Diet: Raw Paleo Diet and Lifestyle Forum
Raw Paleo Diet Forums => Hot Topics => Topic started by: majormark on October 22, 2010, 07:26:29 am
-
His theory sounds a lot like Wrangham's, but he makes some interesting points regarding the intelligence of the gut.
Looks like some people already added some comments about raw meat to his video:
http://www.ted.com/talks/heribert_watzke_the_brain_in_your_gut.html
-
Even if he's right that we are who we are because of cooking, that doesn't mean that the heavily cooked, mushy diet he spoke of is optimal. The changes that occurred from cooking could theoretically all be degenerative.
-
His theory sounds a lot like Wrangham's, but he makes some interesting points regarding the intelligence of the gut.
Looks like some people already added some comments about raw meat to his video:
http://www.ted.com/talks/heribert_watzke_the_brain_in_your_gut.html
That was hilarious. My favourite part was when he said something along the lines of "...our gut shrank 60%...but in my case, it's hard to tell..." while pointing at his oversized gut. A raw food diet would do him some good. The ending quote, "I cook, therefore I am", was also funny.
On a more serious note, I think that it might be plausible that cooking helped increase our brain and shrink our gut. But we have evidence that our metabolic machinery has not fully adapted to cooked food (AGE, HCA, etc). So now that we have big brains and an abundance of food, a raw diet leads to optimal health.
-
To me this theory doesn't make much sense, I certainly wont totally dismiss it but but why would cooked food cause our brains to develop?
I think it's more likely that man evolved to eat meat which lead him only needing to eat once per day. This would promote more time for multidimensional thinking, building, hunting and creating instead of walking around gathering fruit and plants all day just to survive.
So all that spare time they had to think and improve there for enlarged their brain. That sounds more logical to me to say the least.
-
Many raw animal foods are easy to eat, liver, heart, tender meat, brain etc.
I can chew them once and they go down easliy. The ony thing I need to chew thoroughly is certain fats. But they are easy to chew too, but have little moisture unlike flesh, so more chewing is necessary.
He also fails to mention tools (which humans evolved with etc.)
Even birds make houses and chimps make tools, its in our "big brain small gut nature" to make tools and weapons to survive.
-
His only real point for cooking food is that we don't have large k-9s.
-
My contention that humans haven't fully adapted to cooking is the fact that in the realm of HEALING, it is RAW FOOD that delivers the cures.
-
wow I just learned a new word, coctivore...
Yeah baby I am a coctivore ;) ....heh heh...sorry...I couldn't resist saying that
And humans can adapt to anything, don't mean its good for them, what other animal can live its life and smoke a pack of cigarettes everyday :o
-
wow I just learned a new word, coctivore...
Yeah baby I am a coctivore ;) ....heh heh...sorry...I couldn't resist saying that
And humans can adapt to anything, don't mean its good for them, what other animal can live its life and smoke a pack of cigarettes everyday :o
Lol i was thinkig of saying something about that.
-
Yeah baby I am a coctivore ;) ....heh heh...
All women are.