So you'd ask a lab scientist why something he says is bad happens to work in the real world? That sounds like a waste of time to me. If eating fish didn't work then the Eskimos, Samoans, Japanese, etc., would be having health problems from it. They don't, though. Also, none of those groups mentions avoiding fatty fish. In fact, all the groups Dr. Price studied PRIZED animal fats, including fatty fish.
Well, I just mean I'd be curious to hear what he has to say about that; I'm not questioning the fact that those cultures all obviously thrived on eating lots of fatty fish.
I have read Dr. Price's book, and actually own it--I should really re-read it; I haven't for awhile! Traditional foods diets are where I originally started, when I got interested in researching healing through diet about 4-5 years ago.
It just seems to me that sometimes modern people with messed up health need more than just a healthy traditional diet to totally heal, which is why I am interested in Dr. Peat's work. For instance, some of the people that Dr. Price studied ate grains as a good portion of their diets and were still healthy, but that obviously won't work for a lot of people nowadays. Dr. Peat's research is very interesting to me because based on what I have learned from him, I am almost 100% sure I'm hypothyroid, and that that is the underlying cause of my MS diagnosis.
Also, his dietary suggestions, with a raw=paleo slant added, are very very close to what I ended up leaning towards instinctively on my own...sweet fruits, raw dairy, raw honey, raw meat/organs, saturated fats, bone broth. And supplementing thyroid hormone by eating raw bison thyroid makes me feel A LOT better!