Okay so I said I'd post on what I've been up to the last few months.
So back when I started doing the cyclical ketogenic diet, I would notice an inflated effect to my muscles and liked it. And I had to travel quite a bit between June and October (sometimes had to eat at a chow hall). So I pretty much caved and started eating more and more carbs, grains included. I still made sure to eat raw meat and raw fat, but I liked the effects of insulin on growth, and of course the inflated look. I didn't consider the grains to be too bad. My reasoning was that excess carbs (grains) aren't necessarily unhealthy (aka grain=bad), but it is the insulin resistance that develops as a result that is unhealthy, and I was doing plenty of weight lifting which increases insulin sensitivity. I guess there's still things like gluten intolerance, and yes, I noticed some negative side effects when I really started to add more grains. But eventually my body adapted, and I was still getting plenty of raw meat.
My growth though had somewhat stagnated despite changing up my workout plan and trying a few different things. Kind of frustrating, b/c now the extra carbs didn't seem to be helping me bulk or get any stronger. So I went back to the internet, the trusty source for all kinds of knowledge (after you filter through tons of crap), and found this guy Jason Ferruggia. Basically he says that if you want to get bigger and stronger, you have to lift very heavy, with basic movements, and spend no more than 45 mins per session (b/c of how your horomones respond during lifting).
So at the beginning of December I started doing his program - 3 days a week lifting, 5-8 reps to failure, only only 2 sets per exercise, doing large basic movements (squats, deads, weighted pullups and pushups, plus a few others). Once you can do 8 reps, it's time to increase the weight. This was working great, and I mean great. My back and shoulders quickly filled out, which I had negleted somewhat in the past months. Perhaps more importantly, I was stronger every time I set foot in the gym, whether in weight or reps. I did this for about 2-3 weeks, and then took a break between Christmas and the new year. It was the quickest change I had seen in strength or body composition, although it was only for a couple weeks.
So then I got to thinking that perhaps my earlier experiment with VLC and weights was hampered not b/c of the diet, but b/c I wasn't doing the right kind of program in the gym. I was making slow gains with VLC, but definitely not losing anything. Not only that, the carb metabolism made me put on fat with the mucle, in addition to the added digestive problems b/c of mixing all the carbs and meat. So I wanted to find out if I can repeat these results on VLC.
So 1 Jan I started getting back to ketosis, which sucked, but was over in a few days. Then I went back to the gym on the 5th. I was definitely weaker in the gym for the first 7 days, but after the 1st week I had recovered an equal amount of strength from when I left off in carb metabolism. I just finished out my second week, and I have improved a little from when I left off carb metabolism, although the improvements still haven't matched the rapid pace from earlier. I think part of that is b/c heavy squats and deadlifts were new to me, so you have the neurological effects where your body is first learning to recruit more fibers before growing the existing ones, and I may have been reaching the end of that "newbie" phase just as I was starting ketosis.
I also think a good portion is that I've been out of ketosis for a solid 7 months. I have read that gene expression is altered when in ketosis, and I've read it can take 22 weeks for a full adaptation (enzyme and bacterial changes in the gut, enzyme expression in the mitochondria, etc). Even though it may take that long, I've read some studies (
http://www.uk-muscle.co.uk/nutrition-diet-articles/1950-all-about-fats-print.html ) that claim results in the gym should be showing in a few weeks. [I know Lex has said up to a couple years, but I think age and recovery from prior conditions may increase that significantly].
So what this means for me is that I'm going to keep this up for at least a month to give my body some adapation time. As long as I'm making steady gains through February, even if they aren't as dramatic as when I first started, then I'll keep this up for the next 4-6 months or so. I feel optimistic that I'll be able to replicate the results, perhaps do even better on VLC. I can tell I'm not fully adapted yet as the sight/smell of pasta, rice, pizza, etc just gets my mouth watering. I remember not really having these problems when doing VLC for a few months (after having transitioned there from low carb 30-60 grams a day for a good 4-6 months).
In a lot of ways it's important to me that this works out like I hope it will. First, my digestion is so much better this way. And I never really get those strong hunger pangs like I do when eating carbs. After 3-5 days, I could feel that my eyesight and mind were getting much sharper. It was kind of crazy how different it was. And the cold adaptation was amazing. I set my thermostat a good 5 degrees lower (farenheit), and instead of wearing a sweatshirt, I'll often just go shirtless now and feel just fine. I mean, every other metric that I can think of shows just how much better ketosis is than carb metabolism, and I really consider it optimum for the body. I also consider heavy lifting one of the best things you can do as exercise for the body. If done properly, it improves joint strength, increases insulin sensitivity, and makes every day lifting and movement easier and safer - that is so long as you maintain flexibility and don't roid it up like those guys on the magazines.
So really, if ketosis and lifting don't go together, I'll guess I'll be forced to re-evaluated my viewpoint on at least one of these items. I wish there was more study done on this subject. Almost all of the studies done with ketosis are terminated after a week or two, and invariably are done on cooked diets. Seems like I've read quite a bit of conflicting accounts about ketosis and lifting. Guess I'll just have to keep at it and see.