Sully, I love North star, Mary, is great. I use to buy my fat from them too, until they ran out for the reason you mentioned. I sampled the 'other' bison fat. It was pretty rank, as in oxidized. Maybe you got a different lot, but look for the soap smell (unpleasant) and slight burn in the back of the throat. And please don't mention my name if you do talk about it with her. I wouldn't want her to think I am slighting any of their products. Thanks