You probably know these sources already - but just in case:
# New York City: Amaar Milk, Moady Amaar, Phone: (862) 262-4449, Email: m_amaar80@yahoo.com . Organic grass-fed cow and goat dairy products, cheeses, pastured eggs, meats, raw local honey, healthy oils, snacks, more. They deliver to the NY metro area including all of New York City, Long Island, New Jersey, and Westchester. Dairy comes from Pennsylvania farms. Click here for reader feedback on Amar Milk.
# New York City: Udder Milk Creamery Co-op offers milk from two farmers that have mixed herds of cows, including Short Horns, Dutch Belted, Guernseys, Brown Swiss and some Jerseys, and two farmers with all-Jersey herds. They deliver to New York City, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Westchester and all of New Jersey. No delivery charge. Visit
http://www.uddermilk.com/ to become a member.
When I lived in NYC before the internet and was a raw vegan I thought to myself - "Hey, maybe I can get raw milk - that's probably good for me too!" So I called a farm upstate and I never heard such an angry self-righteous person in all my life (and that's a lot to say for a New Yorker). She wanted to know my name and if I had kids and I thought for sure she wanted to report me and get me jailed for all eternity for even thinking about drinking raw milk. I stopped looking - until not long ago when others on the internet helped me find a source here. Lots of farmers won't even put their names on realmilk.com for fear of being attacked by the authorities - but they're out there!
How I found sources was through my local Weston A. Price foundation. Email the person that runs yours and see if they can direct you. They have to be really careful so you might have to go to a meeting or something - but it's worth it. Be as gentle as you can possible be for a Troll.

They scare easy.
http://www.wprice-nyc.org/